Learn
Lesson · Helping Verbs · Not, do and the boxes

Which of the Twelve Boxes Get Used

The tense table has twelve boxes, and a course gives them equal time. A page does not. In one chapter, 216 pronoun subjects are followed by a verb phrase. The simple boxes, present and past, hold 55, and the phrases with a modal in front hold 57. The lab files 3 as progressive.

simple, present and past 55 of 216 with a modal 57 of 216 perfect, any time 4 of 216 progressive, any time 3 of 216 be + participle 4 of 216 no verb found 42 of 216
One chapter, 216 verb phrases after a pronoun

Core ideas

What this lesson establishes

Three ideas, and the last one is about the lab.

1

Twelve boxes are not twelve equal tools

The tense table has twelve boxes: present, past and future, each simple, progressive, perfect and perfect progressive. The lab sorts the phrase after each pronoun into those boxes, and adds groups the table does not draw: be or have as the main verb, be and a participle, which may be the passive or an adjective, and do as a helping verb.

2

Most of a page is in three places

In the chapter the largest groups are be as the main verb (39), a modal in front (57) and the plain present and past (55). Together they hold 151 of the 216. The other groups share the rest.

3

A scan has a group for what it cannot sort

The lab calls it no verb found, and it holds 42 of 216. The rows are printed, and they are the lab being honest: a verb the word list lacks, a pronoun that is an object, he ought to. A count that hides its group for the rest is not a count.

The material

The boxes the chapter hardly uses

The lab files two phrases in 216 as progressive and four as perfect. Read them, because they are the ones taught in class for the most time.

You have been given a table of twelve boxes: present, past and future, each simple, progressive, perfect and perfect progressive. It is a good table. It is also usually taught as if each box mattered the same.

Count and it does not. The lab takes every pronoun in Chapter XXVI, 216 of them, and sorts the verb phrase after each into a box.

Where the 216 land

Be as the main verb holds 38, the largest named group. A modal in front holds 57, and the table under the boxes splits it: 28 with a bare verb straight after, I will try; 27 filed as modal, other, most of them be as the main verb with a modal in front, I should be miserable, it will be as well, and the rest gaps of the kinds “After a Modal, the Verb Is Bare” sorted; one modal perfect, we must have met; and one modal progressive, I will not be wishing. The plain present and past hold 55: past simple 27, present simple 25 and past simple with do 3.

The small groups: be and a participle hold 4, and only one of the four, you are warned, plainly says what was done to the subject; satisfied, resolved and convinced read as states. The perfect holds 4. The progressive holds 3. Forty-two are filed as no verb found.

So the simple boxes and the phrases with a modal in front hold 112 of the 216, just over half. The progressive holds 1.4%.

The rare boxes, read by hand

The three progressives are she has been acting, I will not be wishing and he was now rendering himself agreeable, 3 of 216, 1.4%, and reading the rows by hand finds no more. “Be Is Mostly a Main Verb” finds six -ing forms after be in this same chapter by scan and seven by hand. The difference is that this lab reads only the phrase after a pronoun, and this is being serious, my aunt is going, Mrs. Hurst were going out and his marriage was fast approaching have no pronoun in front.

Why the group for the rest matters

The 42 in no verb found are the lab being honest. Read the rows. Some are an object, as in to use it your father. Some have a word between the pronoun and its verb, as in we all expect, and some a verb the word list lacks, as in she endeavoured to. Five are I cannot, which the lab does not read as can and not. Some are he ought to, where ought is not one of the helping verbs the lab tracks. They are printed so you can sort them yourself.

The whole novel

Counted once over the whole novel, which no page can carry, and quoted here: 8,864 pronoun subjects. Past simple is 18.2%, be as the main verb 15.5%, present simple 12.5%, and a modal or future simple 8.4%. The passive is 3.3%, the past perfect 2.8%, the present perfect 1.8%, and all the progressive phrases together 143 of the 8,864, 1.6%. No verb found is 17.7%.

Today's pages

Switch the lab to the two modern documents. They have 34 pronoun subjects. The simple boxes hold 14, 41.2%. The perfect holds 3, 8.8%. The progressive holds 0. The boxes that a page uses are about the same in 1813 and 2026.

What this does not say

None of this tells you which box to choose. A writer picks a box because of what they mean, and a count of printed words cannot see that. It tells you which boxes to practise first if you have little time, and which to know well enough to read.

Interactive

Helping verbs, counted on one chapter of a novel

Every pronoun, modal, have, be and not in the chapter, and what comes next

how many it looks at—
the rule holds—
share—
pairs the rule covers—
against the rule—
not or an adverb between—
a verb with an ending next—
perfect: have and a participle—
a noun phrase next: the main verb—
have to—
an -ing form next—
share—
a participle next—
an adjective next—
a noun phrase next—
a preposition or place word next—
after a main verb: the old order—
after a joining word—
n't—
a pronoun next: a question—
something else—
simple, present and past—
progressive, any time—
with a modal—
be and a participle—
no verb found—

boxpronoun subjectsshare
The text the figures come from

Method

Sorting a verb phrase into a box

Collect the helping verbs, then look at the word after them.

1

List the helping verbs in a row

Will not be, has been, did. Skip not and short adverb words.

2

Find the main word

The word after the last helping verb: wishing, acting, written, afraid.

3

Match the chain to a box

Have and a participle is a perfect. Be and an -ing word is a progressive. A modal alone is the modal box. Be and a participle is the passive.

4

Say what the box is called by its parts, not its name

Has been acting is present, perfect, progressive: three parts in one phrase. The names are a way to say the parts, not a thing to learn by heart.

Check yourself

Score 0 / 0

Six phrases from the chapter, six boxes

Each line is a verb phrase after a pronoun, and the box the lab gave it.

she thought past simple I hope present simple I am not afraid be as the main verb I will try modal, simple you are warned passive, or an adjective she has been acting present perfect progressive

The first two are the simple boxes. The third, be as the main verb, is a group of its own, and it is the largest named group in the chapter: 39 phrases. The fourth is the modal box, and the future of the table lives there as will and a bare verb. The last two are the rare ones. A phrase with three parts, present, perfect and progressive at once, appears once in 216.

Common mistakes

1
The progressive is the ordinary presentIt is taught first and practised hardest. In the chapter the lab files 3 of 216 phrases as progressive, 1.4%, and the two modern documents give 0 of 34. Counted once over the whole novel and quoted here, with 8,864 pronoun subjects, all the progressive phrases together are 143, which is 1.6%. The plain present and past are far more common.
2
Reading the table as twelve equal toolsThe chapter puts 55 phrases in the simple boxes and 4 in all the perfect boxes together. The perfect is real and needed, and it is rare. A page that spread its phrases equally over twelve boxes would look nothing like this one.
3
Treating no verb found as a failure of the labIt is 42 of 216 because the lab reads every pronoun as a subject, and many are objects. Quoted for the whole novel, the same group is 17.7%. Read the rows and you can sort them by hand.

Check your understanding

✓
Finish when you can sort a verb phrase into its box, and say which boxes carry most of a real page.

You should be able to sort every pronoun-subject verb phrase in a printed chapter into the tense table's boxes or into the extra groups the lab adds, read off the shares, and say which boxes carry most of the writing and which carry almost none.

Note: The twelve boxes are a way to build a phrase. They are not a ranking of what to say. A writer who wants to say that something began before and goes on needs the perfect progressive, however rare it is. This lesson shows what the boxes cost to learn against how often they turn up; it never says which to choose.

Kept in this browser only, for you. Nothing is sent anywhere and nothing checks it. Carry it to another device.

Feedback and recommendations

Something to change about this lesson? Write it down, tick it off when it is handled, and export the list when you want to act on it. Kept in this browser only: nothing is sent anywhere, and nobody is notified.

No recommendations yet for this lesson.